NFL Indianapolis Colts Trading Cards

With real football cards — mounted by hand in our shop — the gift a Colts fan actually displays.

Shop Indianapolis Colts gifts2026 schedule
★★★★★ 4.9 from 100+ reviews 4 plaque sizes Made in USA
Jonathan Taylor 3 Card plaque

Where most gifts start

The two we'd buy ourselves.
Jonathan Taylor 3 Card plaque
Featured plaque

Jonathan Taylor 3 Card Plaque Donruss Fleer Topps 2023 2024 Indianapolis Colts

$26 View →
2025 Donruss NFL Factory Sealed Team Set Indianapolis Colts - Tyler Warren RC hand-collated team set
Fan favorite

2025 Donruss NFL Factory Sealed Team Set Indianapolis Colts - Tyler Warren RC

$11 View →

All Indianapolis Colts products

46 products
Indianapolis Colts 2026 Topps Football team set

PRE-SALE - 2026 Topps Football Indianapolis Colts Team Set - Complete Hand-Collated Card Set - SHIPS AUGUST 25TH, 8/25

$10
2025 2024 Donruss NFL Factory Sealed Team Set 2 Pack Indianapolis Colts Tyler Warren hand-collated team set

2025 2024 Donruss NFL Factory Sealed Team Set 2 Pack Indianapolis Colts Tyler Warren

$18
2025 Donruss NFL Factory Sealed Team Set Indianapolis Colts - Tyler Warren RC hand-collated team set

2025 Donruss NFL Factory Sealed Team Set Indianapolis Colts - Tyler Warren RC

$11
2024 Donruss Factory Sealed Indianapolis Colts NFL Team Set Richardson plaque

2024 Donruss Factory Sealed Indianapolis Colts NFL Team Set Richardson

$7
Peyton Manning 9 Card Legend Pack 2024 2025 Donruss Topps Panini Score Indianapolis Colts plaque

Peyton Manning 9 Card Legend Pack 2024 2025 Donruss Topps Panini Score Indianapolis Colts

$16
20 Card Team Pack Indianapolis Colts Peyton Manning 2025 Score 2024 Donruss plaque

20 Card Team Pack Indianapolis Colts Peyton Manning 2025 Score 2024 Donruss

$10
2025 2024 2023 Donruss NFL Factory Sealed Team Set 3 Pack Indianapolis Colts Tyler Warren hand-collated team set

2025 2024 2023 Donruss NFL Factory Sealed Team Set 3 Pack Indianapolis Colts Tyler Warren

$28
2025 Donruss NFL Factory Team Set + 20 Card Team Pack - Indianapolis Colts - Tyler Warren 337 RC hand-collated team set

2025 Donruss NFL Factory Team Set + 20 Card Team Pack - Indianapolis Colts - Tyler Warren 337 RC

$18
Indianapolis Colts All Time Greats Legends plaque

Indianapolis Colts All Time Greats Legends Plaque 8 Cards Peyton Manning Andrew Luck

$52
2025 Donruss NFL Team Set Indianapolis Colts - Tyler Warren RC hand-collated team set

2025 Donruss NFL Team Set Indianapolis Colts - Tyler Warren RC

$8
2024 SCORE NFL Indianapolis Colts Team Set Gift Pack + 2023 Donruss + 20 Card Pack Anthony Richardson RC Peyton Manning plaque

2024 SCORE NFL Indianapolis Colts Team Set Gift Pack + 2023 Donruss + 20 Card Pack Anthony Richardson RC Peyton Manning

$25
2026 Topps Football Jonathan Taylor 1991 Topps Football #91TF-49

2026 Topps Football Jonathan Taylor 1991 Topps Football #91TF-49

$3
2026 Topps Football Tyler Warren 1991 Topps Football #91TF-48

2026 Topps Football Tyler Warren 1991 Topps Football #91TF-48

$3
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts football stats plaque with 2 trading cards and engraved nameplate, 8x10 fan cave display

Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Hall of Fame Stats Plaque 8x10 2 Cards Prizm, Donruss, Score 2024 2025 2026

$26
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts football plaque with 3 trading cards and engraved nameplate, 8x10 fan cave display

Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Hall of Fame Fan Gift Plaque 8x10 3 Cards Prizm, Donruss, Score 2024 2025 2026

$26
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts football stats plaque with 1 trading card and engraved nameplate, 6x8 fan cave display

Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Hall of Fame Stats Plaque 6x8 1 Card Prizm, Donruss, Score 2024 2025 2026

$18
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts football plaque with 2 trading cards and engraved nameplate, 6x8 fan cave display

Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Hall of Fame Fan Gift Plaque 6x8 2 Cards Prizm, Donruss, Score 2024 2025 2026

$18
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts football plaque with 1 trading card and engraved nameplate, 4x6 fan cave display

Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Hall of Fame Fan Gift Plaque 4x6 1 Card Prizm, Donruss, Score 2024 2025 2026

$14
Indianapolis Colts Stars 2026 Fan Cave Plaque 8x10 3 Cards - Taylor, Buckner, Jones

Indianapolis Colts Stars 2026 Fan Cave Plaque 8x10 3 Cards - Taylor, Buckner, Jones

$26
Indianapolis Colts All-Time Greats Fan Cave Plaque 8x10 3 Cards Peyton Manning Andrew Luck Edgerrin James

Indianapolis Colts All-Time Greats Fan Cave Plaque 8x10 3 Cards Peyton Manning Andrew Luck Edgerrin James

$26
Indianapolis Colts Super Bowl XLI 41 Champions 12" x 15" Eight-Card Plaque Manning Wayne Freeney Donruss Topps

Indianapolis Colts Super Bowl XLI 41 Champions 12" x 15" Eight-Card Plaque Manning Wayne Freeney Donruss Topps

$52
Indianapolis Colts Super Bowl XLI Champions 8x10 3-Card Plaque

Indianapolis Colts Super Bowl XLI Champions 8x10 3-Card Plaque

$26
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts HOF Fan Gift Plaque 8x10 Stats 2 Cards Donruss Score Panini Topps Prizm 2024 2025 2026

Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts HOF Fan Gift Plaque 8x10 Stats 2 Cards Donruss Score Panini Topps Prizm 2024 2025 2026

$26
Peyton Manning 8x10 plaque

Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts HOF Fan Gift Plaque 8x10 3 Cards Donruss Score Panini Topps Prizm 2024 2025 2026

$26

What fans say

From verified FreshDCards customers
★★★★★

“I bought the set for my son thank you.”

Stephen Parker · Verified buyer

★★★★★

“Order was quick, precise and great quality. Great assets for my collection. That's why I always order two or more of the same each time I make a purchase.”

Shon Crook · Verified buyer

★★★★★

“Great product, great service, love dealing with this company!”

Richard Day · Verified buyer

2026 Indianapolis Colts schedule

17 games. 1 bye. Plan the gift around the season.
Show schedule
Wk 1
Sun Sep 13
vsBaltimore Ravens
1 PM
Wk 2
Sun Sep 20
atKansas City Chiefs
8:20 PM
Wk 3
Sun Sep 27
vsHouston Texans
1 PM
Wk 4
Sun Oct 4
atWashington Commanders
9:30 AM London
Wk 5
Sun Oct 11
atPittsburgh Steelers
1 PM
Wk 6
Sun Oct 18
vsTennessee Titans
1 PM
Wk 7
Sun Oct 25
atMinnesota Vikings
1 PM
Wk 8
Sun Nov 1
atJacksonville Jaguars
1 PM
Wk 9
Sun Nov 8
vsDallas Cowboys
1 PM
Wk 10
Sun Nov 15
vsMiami Dolphins
1 PM
Wk 11
Thu Nov 19
atHouston Texans
8:15 PM
Wk 12
Sun Nov 29
vsNY Giants
1 PM
Wk 13
Bye week
Wk 14
Sun Dec 13
atPhiladelphia Eagles
1 PM
Wk 15
Sun Dec 20
atTennessee Titans
1 PM
Wk 16
Sat/Sun Dec 26
vsCincinnati Bengals
TBD
Wk 17
Sun Jan 3
atCleveland Browns
1 PM
Wk 18
Sat/Sun Jan 9
vsJacksonville Jaguars
TBD
Open the full 2026 Indianapolis Colts schedule page →

About Indianapolis Colts cards at FreshDCards

The Horseshoe Crew shows up every Sunday. Indianapolis Colts fans pack Lucas Oil Stadium and carry the Horseshoe across the Heartland.

Colts fans have the easiest hall-of-famer story to tell: Peyton. Then they had Luck for a heartbeat. Jonathan Taylor still runs harder than almost anyone in football, and Tyler Warren is one of the most exciting rookies in years. A Colts fan wants a gift that respects the Manning standard and points at the next one.

Every plaque on this page is built with real licensed cards — Topps, Panini, Donruss — mounted by hand in our shop. Team sets come two ways: factory sealed in their original blister pack, or hand-collated by us. Either makes a gift that gets displayed, not stuffed in a drawer.

If you're shopping for a Colts fan in your life, start with the player they grew up watching.

All-Time GreatsPeyton Manning
Current StarsJonathan TaylorSauce GardnerTyler Warren