NFLNFL Indianapolis Colts Trading Cards1998–2015Hall of Fame · 2021

Peyton Manning Cards & Plaques

Five MVPs on the wall — for the Colts fan who watched 14 seasons.

Shop Peyton Manning Cards & Plaques gifts Card collector's view

★★★★★ 4.9 from 100+ reviews Real licensed cards Made in USA

Indianapolis Colts All-Time Greats Fan Cave Plaque 8x10 3 Cards Peyton Manning Andrew Luck Edgerrin James

Career snapshot

Career: 71,940 passing yards · 539 passing TDs · 251 INTs · 18 seasons · 1998–2015 across Indianapolis Colts and Denver Broncos. Career averages: 65.3% completion · 96.5 passer rating.

Hardware: 2× Super Bowl Champion (XLI, 50), Super Bowl XLI MVP, 5× NFL MVP (record), 14× Pro Bowl, 7× First-Team All-Pro. NFL single-season records for passing yards (5,477) and TDs (55) in 2013. Pro Football Hall of Fame, Class of 2021.

Accolades

★ 2× Super Bowl Champion (XLI, 50)

★ Super Bowl XLI MVP

★ 5× NFL MVP (NFL record)

★ 14× Pro Bowl

★ 7× First-Team All-Pro

★ NFL single-season passing TD record (55 in 2013)

★ NFL single-season passing yards record (5,477 in 2013)

★ Pro Football Hall of Fame, Class of 2021

Where most gifts start

The two SKUs we'd buy ourselves.

Featured plaque

Indianapolis Colts All-Time Greats Fan Cave Plaque 8x10 3 Cards Peyton Manning Andrew Luck Edgerrin James

$26 View →

All Peyton Manning Cards & Plaques products

18 products

Indianapolis Colts All-Time Greats Fan Cave Plaque 8x10 3 Cards Peyton Manning Andrew Luck Edgerrin James

$26

Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts HOF Fan Gift Plaque 8x10 Stats 2 Cards Donruss Score Panini Topps Prizm 2024 2025 2026

$26

Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts HOF Fan Gift Plaque 8x10 3 Cards Donruss Score Panini Topps Prizm 2024 2025 2026

$26

Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts HOF Fan Gift Plaque 6x8 Stats 1 Card Donruss Score Panini Topps Prizm 2024 2025 2026

$18

Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts HOF Fan Gift Plaque 4x6 1 Card Donruss Score Panini Topps Prizm 2024 2025 2026

$14

Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Fan Gift Plaque 12x15 8 Cards Topps Donruss Panini 2024 2025 2026

$52

2013 SCORE Factory Sealed Denver Broncos Peyton Manning Wes Welker

$12

2020 Donruss Factory Sealed Denver Broncos Von Miller Peyton Manning Atwater

$12

Denver Broncos Super Bowl 50 Champions 12" x 15" Eight-Card Plaque Peyton Manning Donruss Topps

$52

2025 2024 2023 Donruss NFL Factory Sealed Team Set 3 Pack Indianapolis Colts Tyler Warren

$28

Indianapolis Colts All Time Greats Legends Plaque 8 Cards Peyton Manning Andrew Luck

$52

Denver Broncos All Time Greats Legends Plaque 8 Cards John Elway Peyton Manning Davis

$52

Donruss Indianapolis Colts 7 Football Card Team Sets 2024 2023 2021 2015 2008 2025 Peyton Manning

$49

Donruss Denver Broncos Team Sets 2025 2024 2023 2019 2016 2013 + Multiyear Pack 2025 Bo Nix

$49

2025 SCORE Riley Leonard + Tyler Warren RC + 20 Card Team Pack Indianapolis Colts Peyton Manning 22024 Donruss

$12

20 Card Team Pack Indianapolis Colts Peyton Manning 2025 Score 2024 Donruss

$10

Peyton Manning Score Donruss 2025 2024 2 Card 6" x 8" Plaque Indianapolis Colts

$18

Peyton Manning 9 Card Legend Pack 2024 2025 Donruss Topps Panini Score Indianapolis Colts

$16

The card collector's view

Manning's flagship rookie is the 1998 Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket Auto #87 RC—the most valuable football card of the late 90s, with high-grade copies clearing five figures. The 1998 Bowman Chrome #1 RC is the iconic base flagship, with refractor parallels carrying premium grading value. The 1998 SP Authentic #14 RC is numbered to 2,000 and remains a top vintage chase. 1998 Topps Chrome and Upper Deck rookies round out the top tier.

About Peyton Manning Cards & Plaques at FreshDCards

The most prolific passer in NFL history at retirement. Peyton Manning won five NFL MVPs—still a record by two—threw for 71,940 career yards and 539 touchdowns, and set the modern single-season records for passing yards (5,477) and touchdowns (55) at age 37 in 2013. Two Super Bowl rings, one with the Colts (XLI, 2006) and one with the Broncos (50, 2015) on the way out. Fourteen Pro Bowls, seven First-Team All-Pros. The #1 overall pick in 1998, brother to Eli, son to Archie. Pro Football Hall of Fame, Class of 2021.

More NFL Indianapolis Colts Trading Cards gifts →

Shop the full NFL Indianapolis Colts Trading Cards collection

40 products · plaques · team sets