NFL Indianapolis Colts Trading Cards

With real football cards — mounted by hand in our shop — the gift a Colts fan actually displays.

Shop Indianapolis Colts gifts2026 schedule
★★★★★ 4.9 from 100+ reviews 4 plaque sizes Made in USA
Jonathan Taylor 3 Card Plaque Donruss Fleer Topps 2023 2024 Indianapolis Colts

Where most gifts start

The two SKUs we'd buy ourselves.
Jonathan Taylor 3 Card Plaque Donruss Fleer Topps 2023 2024 Indianapolis Colts
Featured plaque

Jonathan Taylor 3 Card Plaque Donruss Fleer Topps 2023 2024 Indianapolis Colts

$26 View →
2025 Donruss NFL Factory Sealed Team Set Indianapolis Colts - Tyler Warren RC
Gateway set

2025 Donruss NFL Factory Sealed Team Set Indianapolis Colts - Tyler Warren RC

$11 View →

What fans say

From verified FreshDCards customers
★★★★★

“I bought the set for my son thank you.”

Stephen Parker · Verified buyer

★★★★★

“Order was quick, precise and great quality. Great assets for my collection. That's why I always order two or more of the same each time I make a purchase.”

Shon Crook · Verified buyer

★★★★★

“Great product, great service, love dealing with this company!”

Richard Day · Verified buyer

2026 Indianapolis Colts schedule

17 games. 1 bye. Plan the gift around the season.
Show schedule
Wk 1
Sun Sep 13
vsBaltimore Ravens
1 PM
Wk 2
Sun Sep 20
atKansas City Chiefs
8:20 PM
Wk 3
Sun Sep 27
vsHouston Texans
1 PM
Wk 4
Sun Oct 4
atWashington Commanders
9:30 AM London
Wk 5
Sun Oct 11
atPittsburgh Steelers
1 PM
Wk 6
Sun Oct 18
vsTennessee Titans
1 PM
Wk 7
Sun Oct 25
atMinnesota Vikings
1 PM
Wk 8
Sun Nov 1
atJacksonville Jaguars
1 PM
Wk 9
Sun Nov 8
vsDallas Cowboys
1 PM
Wk 10
Sun Nov 15
vsMiami Dolphins
1 PM
Wk 11
Thu Nov 19
atHouston Texans
8:15 PM
Wk 12
Sun Nov 29
vsNY Giants
1 PM
Wk 13
Bye week
Wk 14
Sun Dec 13
atPhiladelphia Eagles
1 PM
Wk 15
Sun Dec 20
atTennessee Titans
1 PM
Wk 16
Sat/Sun Dec 26
vsCincinnati Bengals
TBD
Wk 17
Sun Jan 3
atCleveland Browns
1 PM
Wk 18
Sat/Sun Jan 9
vsJacksonville Jaguars
TBD

About Indianapolis Colts cards at FreshDCards

Colts fans have the easiest hall-of-famer story to tell: Peyton. Then they had Luck for a heartbeat. Jonathan Taylor still runs harder than almost anyone in football, and Tyler Warren is one of the most exciting rookies in years. A Colts fan wants a gift that respects the Manning standard and points at the next one.

Every plaque on this page is built with real licensed cards — Topps, Panini, Donruss — mounted by hand in our shop. Team sets come two ways: factory sealed in their original blister pack, or hand-collated by us. Either makes a gift that gets displayed, not stuffed in a drawer.

If you're shopping for a Colts fan in your life, start with the player they grew up watching.

All-Time GreatsPeyton Manning
Current StarsJonathan TaylorTyler Warren