MLBMLB New York Yankees1982–1995

Don Mattingly Cards & Plaques

Donnie Baseball and the 1985 MVP on the wall — for the Yankees fan.

Shop Don Mattingly Cards & Plaques giftsCard collector's view
★★★★★ 4.9 from 100+ reviews Real licensed cards Made in USA
Don Mattingly New York Yankees Fan Gift Plaque 8x10 3 Cards Topps, Bowman 2024 2025 2026

Career snapshot

1985 AL MVP. 6× All-Star. 9× Gold Glove (1B). 3× Silver Slugger. 1984 AL batting title. Career: .307 average, 2,153 hits, 222 home runs. Number 23 retired by the Yankees.

Accolades

★ 1985 AL MVP

★ 6× MLB All-Star

★ 9× Gold Glove (first base)

★ 3× Silver Slugger

★ 1984 AL batting title (.343)

★ Captain of the New York Yankees (1991–1995)

★ Played all 14 MLB seasons in pinstripes

★ Number 23 retired by the New York Yankees

Where most gifts start

The two SKUs we'd buy ourselves.
Don Mattingly New York Yankees Fan Gift Plaque 8x10 3 Cards Topps, Bowman 2024 2025 2026
Featured plaque

Don Mattingly New York Yankees Fan Gift Plaque 8x10 3 Cards Topps, Bowman 2024 2025 2026

$26 View →

The card collector's view

The cornerstone is the 1984 Donruss #248 — among the most iconic baseball cards of the 80s, the rookie that defines the era for many collectors. The 1984 Fleer #131 and 1984 Topps #8 are companion rookies. 1985 Topps Glossy and Donruss Diamond Kings offer post-RC chase. Modern Yankees fans hunt his Topps Heritage retro autographs and Topps Stadium Club photo-variant inserts.

About Don Mattingly Cards & Plaques at FreshDCards

Donnie Baseball. Don Mattingly played all fourteen seasons in pinstripes and became the most beloved Yankee of the 80s. The 1985 AL MVP. Six All-Star nods. Nine Gold Gloves at first base. Captain of the Yankees from 1991 to his retirement in 1995. A back injury cut the prime short, but the standard was set: .307 lifetime average, six straight 200-hit seasons. His number 23 was retired by the Yankees. Hall of Fame voters never reached 75%, but Yankees fans don't care.

More MLB New York Yankees gifts →

Shop the full MLB New York Yankees collection

119 products · plaques · team sets