Shopping for a Don Mattingly fan? Maybe it's a dad or grandpa who grew up watching Donnie Baseball at first base in the Bronx. These are real, licensed Don Mattingly cards: a ready-to-give Fan Bundle, wood plaques for the wall, and Yankees legends gifts for the fan who knows the history. Start with our top pick, or jump to a budget.
Updated October 2026 · Prices and availability checked against our live inventory.
Don Mattingly Fan Bundle: 2026 Yankees Team Set + 6 Mattingly Cards
The gift that connects the fan who grew up on Donnie Baseball to today's Yankees: six Mattingly cards plus the whole 2026 roster.
- 6 different Don Mattingly cards from recent licensed Topps and Bowman sets, each in a penny sleeve
- All 25 Yankees cards from 2026 Topps Series 1 & 2, led by Aaron Judge
- The player pack ships sealed in a team bag, ready to give
Costs less than buying the team set and the player pack on their own. See what's inside →
Quick Picks
- Top pick: Don Mattingly Fan Bundle: 2026 Yankees Team Set + 6 Mattingly Cards ($37)
- For the desk: Don Mattingly 2-Card Plaque (6x8) ($18)
- Six Yankees legends: Yankees 6 Card Legends Pack: Mattingly, Jeter, Mantle and More ($21)
- The big wall piece: Yankees All-Time Greats 8-Card Plaque (12x15) ($52)
Don Mattingly Gifts Under $20
Small gifts for a desk, a shelf or a stocking, or a way to round out a bigger present.
Don Mattingly 2-Card Plaque (6x8)
Two licensed Don Mattingly cards on solid wood with an engraved nameplate, ready for the office or the fan cave.
Don Mattingly Card Plaque (4x6)
One licensed Don Mattingly card on solid wood with an engraved nameplate. Fits on a desk or a shelf.
Don Mattingly 6 Card Player Pack
Six Don Mattingly cards from recent licensed sets like Topps, Bowman, Archives, Stadium Club and Heritage, all in his Yankees uniform, each in a penny sleeve, sent in a sealed team bag.
Don Mattingly Gifts $20 to $50
The sweet spot: a full gift that looks great unwrapped.
Don Mattingly Fan Bundle: 2026 Yankees Team Set + 6 Mattingly Cards
Six different Don Mattingly cards plus every Yankees card from 2026 Topps Series 1 & 2, already put together as one gift.
Don Mattingly 3-Card Plaque (8x10)
Three licensed Don Mattingly cards under clear acrylic with an engraved nameplate, ready for the wall.
Yankees 6 Card Legends Pack: Mattingly, Jeter, Mantle and More
One card each of six Yankees greats: Don Mattingly, Derek Jeter, Mickey Mantle, Babe Ruth, Mariano Rivera and Aaron Judge.
The Premium Don Mattingly Gift
For the fan who has everything: eight Yankees legends and a centerpiece for the fan cave.
Yankees All-Time Greats 8-Card Plaque (12x15)
Mattingly alongside Ruth, Gehrig, Mantle, Berra, Jeter, Rivera and Judge on one big plaque. The fan cave centerpiece.
Gift Combos: Build a Bigger Gift
Want a gift that feels bigger? Each combo pairs something for the wall or the desk with the Fan Bundle. One click puts everything in your cart and takes you to checkout.
Don Mattingly Fan Bundle + Mattingly 6x8 Plaque
The Fan Bundle to open and a Mattingly plaque for the desk or shelf.
Don Mattingly Fan Bundle + Mattingly 3-Card Plaque
Six Mattingly cards and the 2026 roster, plus three more Mattingly cards on the wall.
Don Mattingly Fan Bundle + Yankees Legends Pack
The Fan Bundle plus cards of Mattingly, Jeter, Mantle, Ruth and more. For the fan who knows the history.
Yankees Legends 12x15 Plaque + Don Mattingly Fan Bundle
Eight Yankees legends on the big plaque, plus the Fan Bundle to open on Christmas morning.
Don Mattingly Gift FAQ
When should I order for Christmas?
Plaques are hand-mounted in our shop and ship in 3-4 business days. For Christmas delivery, order by December 7.
Are these real Don Mattingly cards?
Yes. Every plaque, pack and set uses genuine licensed cards, never prints or reproductions. Our Mattingly plaques and packs use cards from recent licensed sets like Topps and Bowman, which still honor him today. The exact card on a plaque may vary slightly from the one pictured, but it is always a licensed card of Don Mattingly.
What's in the Don Mattingly Fan Bundle?
A pack of six different Don Mattingly cards from recent licensed Topps and Bowman sets, each in a penny sleeve, plus the 25-card 2026 Topps Series 1 & 2 Yankees team set led by Aaron Judge. The Mattingly cards come in the player pack, which ships sealed in a team bag. See every Mattingly card and plaque we carry on our Don Mattingly page.
Why do Yankees fans love Don Mattingly?
He spent his whole 14-season career in pinstripes, from 1982 to 1995. He won the 1984 American League batting title with a .343 average, was named AL MVP in 1985, won nine Gold Gloves at first base and made six All-Star teams. He was Yankees captain from 1991 to 1995, finished with a .307 career average, and the Yankees retired his number 23 in 1997.
Can you make a custom Don Mattingly plaque?
Usually, yes. Email david@freshdcards.com and we'll reply the same day.