Few things bring Colts fans together like looking back at the legends who wore the horseshoe and earned the game's highest individual honors. Here is a warm celebration of the Indianapolis Colts players who made it to the Pro Bowl and left their mark on this proud franchise forever.
Peyton Manning: 11-Time Pro Bowler (Hall of Fame)
Peyton Manning is simply the gold standard of Indianapolis Colts football, and his 11 Pro Bowl selections during his time with the team reflect a career that redefined what a quarterback could be. He transformed the Colts into a perennial contender and gave fans some of the most thrilling football moments in the franchise's history. A first-ballot Hall of Famer, Manning's legacy in Indianapolis is about as close to timeless as it gets.
Shop the Peyton Manning plaque ($52) →
Jonathan Taylor: 3-Time Pro Bowler
Jonathan Taylor announced himself as one of the most dynamic running backs in the league during his tenure with the Colts, earning 3 Pro Bowl selections that validated what Indianapolis fans already knew. His powerful, determined running style made him must-watch football on Sundays and a cornerstone of the Colts backfield. Taylor gave this fan base so many reasons to cheer, and his Pro Bowl honors stand as a lasting tribute to what he brought to the horseshoe.
Shop the Jonathan Taylor plaque ($52) →
The Whole Lineup on One Plaque
Can't pick just one? The Indianapolis Colts All-Time Greats plaque brings the franchise legends together on a single piece.
Shop the Indianapolis Colts All-Time Greats plaque ($52) →
The Complete List of Indianapolis Colts Pro Bowlers
Every player selected to the Pro Bowl as a member of the Indianapolis Colts, ranked by number of selections.
| Player | Pro Bowl Selections |
|---|---|
| Gino Marchetti (Hall of Fame) | 11 |
| Peyton Manning (Hall of Fame) | 11 |
| Johnny Unitas (Hall of Fame) | 10 |
| Jim Parker (Hall of Fame) | 8 |
| Marvin Harrison (Hall of Fame) | 8 |
| Quenton Nelson | 8 |
| Dwight Freeney (Hall of Fame) | 7 |
| Lenny Moore (Hall of Fame) | 7 |
| Chris Hinton | 6 |
| Raymond Berry (Hall of Fame) | 6 |
| Reggie Wayne | 6 |
| Art Donovan (Hall of Fame) | 5 |
| Bob Vogel | 5 |
| Jeff Saturday | 5 |
| John Mackey (Hall of Fame) | 5 |
| Robert Mathis | 5 |
| Alan Ameche | 4 |
| Andrew Luck | 4 |
| Edgerrin James (Hall of Fame) | 4 |
| Mike Curtis | 4 |
| Ray Donaldson | 4 |
| Rohn Stark | 4 |
| Ryan Kelly | 4 |
| T. Y. Hilton | 4 |
| Darius Leonard | 3 |
| Eric Dickerson (Hall of Fame) | 3 |
| Jonathan Taylor | 3 |
| Tarik Glenn | 3 |
| Ted Hendricks (Hall of Fame) | 3 |
| Antoine Bethea | 2 |
| Bill Curry | 2 |
| Bob Sanders | 2 |
| Clarence Verdin | 2 |
| DeForest Buckner | 2 |
| Jack Doyle | 2 |
| Jerry Logan | 2 |
| Bruce Laird | 1 |
| Bubba Smith | 1 |
| Cato June | 1 |
| Dallas Clark | 1 |
| Dean Biasucci | 1 |
| Duane Bickett | 1 |
| Eric Ebron | 1 |
| Gardner Minshew | 1 |
| Jim Harbaugh | 1 |
| Joseph Addai | 1 |
| Ken Dilger | 1 |
| Kenny Moore II | 1 |
| Luke Rhodes | 1 |
| Marshall Faulk (Hall of Fame) | 1 |
| Mike Vanderjagt | 1 |
| Norm Bulaich | 1 |
| Pat McAfee | 1 |
| Rick Volk | 1 |
| Ron Solt | 1 |
| Will Wolford | 1 |
| Zaire Franklin | 1 |
Browse all Indianapolis Colts plaques →
Each plaque includes genuine licensed trading cards. The exact card may vary slightly from the one pictured; you'll always get a genuine licensed card of this player.