MLBMLB Pittsburgh Pirates2009–presentActive

Andrew McCutchen Cards & Plaques

An MVP and the 2013 Bucs run on the wall — for the Pirates fan who remembers.

Shop Andrew McCutchen Cards & Plaques giftsCard collector's view
★★★★★ 4.9 from 100+ reviews Real licensed cards Made in USA
Pittsburgh Pirates All Time Greats Legends plaque

Career snapshot

Stats updated annually

2013 NL MVP. 5× All-Star, 4× Silver Slugger, 2012 NL Gold Glove (center field). ~2,000 career hits, 320+ home runs, 200+ stolen bases. 2015 Roberto Clemente Award.

Accolades

★ 2013 NL MVP (unanimous)

★ 5× MLB All-Star (2011–2015)

★ 4× Silver Slugger (2012–2015)

★ 2012 NL Gold Glove (center field)

★ 2015 Roberto Clemente Award (humanitarian)

★ Led Pirates to three straight playoff appearances (2013–2015)

★ 11th overall pick of the 2005 MLB Draft

★ Reunited with the Pirates in 2023 for a veteran homecoming

Looking for a gift for an Andrew McCutchen fan?

Our Pirates gift guide has team sets, fan bundles, wall plaques and one-click gift combos.

See the Pirates gift guide →

Where most gifts start

The two SKUs we'd buy ourselves.
Pittsburgh Pirates All Time Greats Legends plaque
Featured plaque

Pittsburgh Pirates All Time Greats Legends Plaque 8 Cards Roberto Clemente McCutchen Stargell

$52 View →

The card collector's view

The 2005 Bowman Chrome Draft Refractor Auto is the cornerstone — RC chase card, high-grade copies move steadily as McCutchen's career legacy crystallizes. The 2008 Topps Chrome RC Refractor #198 is the accessible base rookie. His MVP year produced the 2013 Topps Update Gold Border and Bowman Chrome Black parallels as showcase pieces. Modern Pirates fans hunt his Topps Heritage retro autographs and Stadium Club photo-variant inserts.

About Andrew McCutchen Cards & Plaques at FreshDCards

The face of the Pirates' brief but unforgettable contention window — the 2013, 2014, and 2015 playoff runs that ended a 20-year postseason drought. McCutchen won the 2013 NL MVP unanimously, dragged the Steel City back to October, and became the most beloved Pirate since Stargell. Six years and four teams later, he came home in 2023. Now a veteran presence on a young Bucs roster led by Paul Skenes. The 11th overall pick of 2005 chose to wear black and gold one more time.

More MLB Pittsburgh Pirates gifts →

Shop the full MLB Pittsburgh Pirates collection

80 products · plaques · team sets