Few things bring Leafs Nation together like celebrating the players who wore the blue and white and shone brightest on hockey's biggest stage. Here is every Toronto Maple Leafs All-Star, honoured for the moments that made us proud.
Mitch Marner: 3-Time All-Star
With three All-Star selections earned during his time as a Maple Leaf, Mitch Marner proved himself one of the most electrifying playmakers to ever pull on the blue and white. His vision, creativity, and sheer love for the game lit up Scotiabank Arena night after night. For Leafs fans, a Marner jersey hanging in the fan cave is a tribute to pure, joyful hockey.
Shop the Mitch Marner plaque ($26) →
Auston Matthews: 2-Time All-Star
Auston Matthews earned two All-Star nods as a Maple Leaf, cementing his place among the most gifted goal scorers in franchise history. His powerful shot and quiet confidence made him must-watch hockey and gave a generation of Toronto fans something truly special to cheer for. Wearing number 34 became a statement of belief in a brighter era of Leafs hockey.
Shop the Auston Matthews plaque ($26) →
William Nylander: All-Star
William Nylander earned an All-Star selection during his time with the Maple Leafs, dazzling fans with his silky stride and sharp offensive instincts. He became one of the most skilled and entertaining players to skate for Toronto in the modern era. A Nylander piece in any fan cave is a nod to the kind of effortless, exciting hockey that keeps Leafs Nation coming back.
Shop the William Nylander plaque ($18) →
The Complete List of Toronto Maple Leafs All-Stars
Every player selected to the NHL All-Star Game as a member of the Toronto Maple Leafs, ranked by number of selections.
| Player | All-Star Selections |
|---|---|
| Frank Mahovlich (Hall of Fame) | 9 |
| Dave Keon (Hall of Fame) | 8 |
| Mats Sundin (Hall of Fame) | 8 |
| George Armstrong (Hall of Fame) | 7 |
| Jimmy Thomson | 7 |
| Sid Smith | 7 |
| Tim Horton (Hall of Fame) | 7 |
| Harry Watson | 6 |
| Ted Kennedy (Hall of Fame) | 6 |
| Allan Stanley (Hall of Fame) | 5 |
| Bob Pulford (Hall of Fame) | 5 |
| Dick Duff (Hall of Fame) | 5 |
| Gus Mortson | 5 |
| Billy Harris | 4 |
| Bob Baun | 4 |
| Johnny Bower (Hall of Fame) | 4 |
| Larry Hillman | 4 |
| Ron Ellis | 4 |
| Ron Stewart | 4 |
| Tomáš Kaberle | 4 |
| Turk Broda (Hall of Fame) | 4 |
| Bill Barilko | 3 |
| Börje Salming | 3 |
| Carl Brewer | 3 |
| Darryl Sittler (Hall of Fame) | 3 |
| Eddie Shack | 3 |
| Fleming Mackell | 3 |
| Howie Meeker | 3 |
| Jim Morrison | 3 |
| Joe Klukay | 3 |
| Kent Douglas | 3 |
| Max Bentley (Hall of Fame) | 3 |
| Mitch Marner | 3 |
| Phil Kessel | 3 |
| Red Kelly (Hall of Fame) | 3 |
| Rick Vaive | 3 |
| Tod Sloan | 3 |
| Vic Lynn | 3 |
| Al Iafrate | 2 |
| Auston Matthews | 2 |
| Bill Ezinicki | 2 |
| Bill Juzda | 2 |
| Bob Nevin | 2 |
| Cal Gardner | 2 |
| Doug Gilmour (Hall of Fame) | 2 |
| Ed Litzenberger | 2 |
| Félix Potvin | 2 |
| Garth Boesch | 2 |
| Harry Lumley (Hall of Fame) | 2 |
| Jim Pappin | 2 |
| John MacMillan | 2 |
| Lanny McDonald (Hall of Fame) | 2 |
| Norm Ullman (Hall of Fame) | 2 |
| Paul Henderson | 2 |
| Al Smith | 1 |
| Andy Bathgate (Hall of Fame) | 1 |
| Bert Olmstead (Hall of Fame) | 1 |
| Bob Dawes | 1 |
| Bob Goldham | 1 |
| Bob Manno | 1 |
| Brian Conacher | 1 |
| Bruce Gamble | 1 |
| Bud Poile (Hall of Fame) | 1 |
| Curtis Joseph | 1 |
| Dave Andreychuk (Hall of Fame) | 1 |
| Dave Burrows | 1 |
| Dave Ellett | 1 |
| Dion Phaneuf | 1 |
| Dmitry Yushkevich | 1 |
| Don McKenney | 1 |
| Don Metz | 1 |
| Don Simmons | 1 |
| Duane Rupp | 1 |
| Fern Flaman | 1 |
| Frank Mathers (Hall of Fame) | 1 |
| Frederik Andersen | 1 |
| Gary Leeman | 1 |
| Gary Roberts | 1 |
| Gaye Stewart | 1 |
| Gerry Ehman | 1 |
| Hugh Bolton | 1 |
| Ian Turnbull | 1 |
| Jim McKenny | 1 |
| Joffrey Lupul | 1 |
| Larry Murphy (Hall of Fame) | 1 |
| Leo Komarov | 1 |
| Les Costello | 1 |
| Marcel Pronovost (Hall of Fame) | 1 |
| Mike Gartner (Hall of Fame) | 1 |
| Mike Walton | 1 |
| Miroslav Fryčer | 1 |
| Morgan Rielly | 1 |
| Murray Oliver | 1 |
| Pete Stemkowski | 1 |
| Ray Timgren | 1 |
| Robert Picard | 1 |
| Rudy Migay | 1 |
| Syl Apps (Hall of Fame) | 1 |
| Terry Sawchuk (Hall of Fame) | 1 |
| Vincent Damphousse | 1 |
| Wally Stanowski | 1 |
| Wayne Carleton | 1 |
| Wayne Thomas | 1 |
| Wendel Clark | 1 |
| William Nylander | 1 |
Each plaque includes genuine licensed trading cards. The exact card may vary slightly from the one pictured; you'll always get a genuine licensed card of this player.