The Greatest Pittsburgh Penguins All-Stars of All Time

Few things bring Penguins fans together like celebrating the legends who wore the black and gold and took their brilliance to the All-Star stage. Here is a look at every Pittsburgh Penguin who earned that honor, and the legacies that made them unforgettable.

Pittsburgh Penguins plaquePittsburgh Penguins plaque

Mario Lemieux: 10-Time All-Star (Hall of Fame)

Simply put, Mario Lemieux is the greatest Penguin who ever lived, and his 10 All-Star selections during his time with the team tell only part of the story. He carried the franchise on his back through its darkest years, delivered two Stanley Cup championships, and played the game with a grace and power that left arenas speechless. Decades later, his number 66 hangs in the rafters and his name is spoken with reverence in every Penguins fan cave worth its salt.

Mario Lemieux Pittsburgh Penguins plaque

Shop the Mario Lemieux plaque ($26) →

Sidney Crosby: 3-Time All-Star

Sidney Crosby arrived in Pittsburgh as the most anticipated prospect in a generation, and he delivered on every bit of that promise, earning 3 All-Star selections during his celebrated run with the team. Known as much for his ferocious compete level as his jaw-dropping skill, he led the Penguins to multiple Stanley Cup titles and became one of the most decorated players in NHL history. For a generation of fans, watching Crosby wear the Penguins crest was nothing short of a privilege.

Sidney Crosby Pittsburgh Penguins plaque

Shop the Sidney Crosby plaque ($26) →

The Complete List of Pittsburgh Penguins All-Stars

Every player selected to the NHL All-Star Game as a member of the Pittsburgh Penguins, ranked by number of selections.

Player All-Star Selections
Mario Lemieux (Hall of Fame) 10
Jaromír Jágr 6
Paul Coffey (Hall of Fame) 5
Evgeni Malkin 4
Jean Pronovost 4
Kris Letang 4
Greg Polis 3
Kevin Stevens 3
Sidney Crosby 3
Alex Kovalev 2
Dave Burrows 2
Ken Schinkel 2
Lowell MacDonald 2
Marc-André Fleury 2
Randy Carlyle 2
Rick Kehoe 2
Bob Woytowich 1
Bryan Trottier (Hall of Fame) 1
Dean Prentice 1
Jake Guentzel 1
James Neal 1
Joe Mullen (Hall of Fame) 1
John Cullen 1
Kevin Hatcher 1
Larry Murphy (Hall of Fame) 1
Mark Recchi (Hall of Fame) 1
Martin Straka 1
Michel Dion 1
Mike Bullard 1
Pierre Larouche 1
Rick Tocchet 1
Rob Brown 1
Ron Francis (Hall of Fame) 1
Ron Stackhouse 1
Sergei Gonchar 1
Syl Apps (Hall of Fame) 1
Tristan Jarry 1

Each plaque includes genuine licensed trading cards. The exact card may vary slightly from the one pictured; you'll always get a genuine licensed card of this player.

Back to blog