Few franchises inspire the kind of fierce, lifelong devotion that the Buffalo Bills do, and a big part of that love comes from the legends who wore the blue and red with everything they had. Here is a celebration of the greatest Pro Bowlers in Bills history, the players whose excellence put Buffalo on the NFL map and kept it there.
Bruce Smith: 11-Time Pro Bowler (Hall of Fame)
Bruce Smith is widely regarded as the greatest defensive player in Bills history, and his 11 Pro Bowl selections during his time with Buffalo tell you everything you need to know about his dominance. A Hall of Famer who terrorized opposing offenses for years, Smith set the standard for what a pass rusher could be. His legacy is woven into the very identity of this franchise.
Shop the Bruce Smith plaque ($18) →
Jim Kelly: 5-Time Pro Bowler (Hall of Fame)
Jim Kelly was the heart and soul of the Bills dynasty, earning five Pro Bowl nods and leading Buffalo to an unprecedented four consecutive Super Bowl appearances. His competitiveness, toughness, and leadership made him one of the most beloved quarterbacks of his era. A Hall of Famer and a true Buffalo icon, Kelly's number has been retired and his memory lives on in every Bills fan.
Shop the Jim Kelly plaque ($52) →
Thurman Thomas: 5-Time Pro Bowler (Hall of Fame)
Thurman Thomas was one of the most complete backs of his generation, earning five Pro Bowl selections while forming the offensive backbone of those legendary Bills teams alongside Jim Kelly. His ability to run and catch out of the backfield made him nearly impossible to defend. A Hall of Famer, Thomas remains a symbol of what made those Bills squads so special.
Shop the Thurman Thomas plaque ($18) →
Josh Allen: 4-Time Pro Bowler
Josh Allen grew into one of the most electrifying players in the NFL during his time building the Bills back into a perennial contender, earning four Pro Bowl selections along the way. His combination of arm strength, athleticism, and sheer will to win captured the hearts of Bills fans everywhere. Allen represents the proud next chapter of a franchise rich with quarterback tradition.
Shop the Josh Allen plaque ($52) →
James Cook: 2-Time Pro Bowler
James Cook announced himself as one of the most exciting backs in the league, earning two Pro Bowl selections and giving the Bills a dangerous weapon in their backfield. His speed and explosiveness made him a highlight-reel talent that fans quickly grew to love. Cook's back-to-back Pro Bowls are a testament to how quickly he established himself among the best at his position.
Shop the James Cook plaque ($52) →
The Whole Lineup on One Plaque
Can't pick just one? The Buffalo Bills All-Time Greats plaque brings the franchise legends together on a single piece.
Shop the Buffalo Bills All-Time Greats plaque ($52) →
The Complete List of Buffalo Bills Pro Bowlers
Every player selected to the Pro Bowl as a member of the Buffalo Bills, ranked by number of selections.
| Player | Pro Bowl Selections |
|---|---|
| Bruce Smith (Hall of Fame) | 11 |
| Billy Shaw (Hall of Fame) | 8 |
| Ruben Brown | 8 |
| Andre Reed (Hall of Fame) | 7 |
| Steve Tasker | 7 |
| Jack Kemp | 6 |
| Kyle Williams | 6 |
| Mike Stratton | 6 |
| O. J. Simpson (Hall of Fame) | 6 |
| Butch Byrd | 5 |
| Cornelius Bennett | 5 |
| Dion Dawkins | 5 |
| Fred Smerlas | 5 |
| George Saimes | 5 |
| Jim Kelly (Hall of Fame) | 5 |
| Joe DeLamielleure (Hall of Fame) | 5 |
| Stew Barber | 5 |
| Thurman Thomas (Hall of Fame) | 5 |
| Ernie Warlick | 4 |
| Jim Dunaway | 4 |
| Josh Allen | 4 |
| Stefon Diggs | 4 |
| Tom Sestak | 4 |
| James Cook III | 3 |
| Joe Cribbs | 3 |
| Kent Hull | 3 |
| LeSean McCoy | 3 |
| Robert James | 3 |
| Shane Conlan | 3 |
| Aaron Schobel | 2 |
| Andre Roberts | 2 |
| Brian Moorman | 2 |
| Darryl Talley | 2 |
| Eric Moulds | 2 |
| Howard Ballard | 2 |
| Jairus Byrd | 2 |
| James Cook | 2 |
| Jason Peters | 2 |
| Jim Richter | 2 |
| Richie Incognito | 2 |
| Takeo Spikes | 2 |
| Tre'Davious White | 2 |
| Will Wolford | 2 |
| Baltimore Ravens | 1 |
| Ben Williams | 1 |
| Bryce Paup | 1 |
| C. J. Spiller | 1 |
| Connor McGovern | 1 |
| Dave Foley | 1 |
| Dawson Knox | 1 |
| Drew Bledsoe | 1 |
| Frank Lewis | 1 |
| Greg Bell | 1 |
| Henry Jones | 1 |
| J.D. Hill | 1 |
| James Lofton (Hall of Fame) | 1 |
| Jerry Butler | 1 |
| Jordan Poyer | 1 |
| Larry Centers | 1 |
| Lorenzo Alexander | 1 |
| Marshawn Lynch | 1 |
| Matt Milano | 1 |
| Micah Hyde | 1 |
| Mike Schneck | 1 |
| Mitch Morse | 1 |
| Nate Clements | 1 |
| Nate Odomes | 1 |
| Rodger Saffold | 1 |
| Sam Adams | 1 |
| Sam Cowart | 1 |
| Sam Gash | 1 |
| Scott Norwood | 1 |
| Stephon Gilmore | 1 |
| Ted Washington | 1 |
| Terrence McGee | 1 |
| Travis Henry | 1 |
| Tremaine Edmunds | 1 |
| Tyrod Taylor | 1 |
| Zach Brown | 1 |
Browse all Buffalo Bills plaques →
Each plaque includes genuine licensed trading cards. The exact card may vary slightly from the one pictured; you'll always get a genuine licensed card of this player.