Every New York Yankees Hall of Famer

June 25, 2026

Few franchises in sports history have called so many legends their own. Here is every New York Yankees Hall of Famer, the men whose names are woven into the fabric of baseball itself.

Derek Jeter

The Captain was the face and soul of the Yankees for more than two decades, leading the franchise to five World Series titles with a competitiveness and class that defined his entire career. Jeter had an uncanny ability to rise to the biggest moments, delivering memories that Yankees fans will treasure forever. He represented everything a Yankee was supposed to be, on and off the field.

Shop the Derek Jeter plaque ($52) →

Mickey Mantle

The Commerce Comet combined raw power and breathtaking speed in a way that left fans absolutely awestruck throughout his career in pinstripes. Mantle was the heart of Yankees baseball through some of the franchise's greatest championship runs and carried the weight of Yankee Stadium on his shoulders with remarkable grace. For so many fans who grew up watching him, no player ever meant more.

Shop the Mickey Mantle plaque ($26) →

Lou Gehrig

The Iron Horse was the quiet, unshakeable backbone of the Yankees lineup for nearly two decades. Gehrig played through pain and adversity with a dignity that made him beloved far beyond the ballpark. His farewell speech at Yankee Stadium remains one of the most moving moments in all of American sports.

Shop the Lou Gehrig plaque ($26) →

Yogi Berra

Yogi Berra was a champion in every sense of the word, earning more World Series rings than almost anyone who ever played the game. Behind the plate he was as smart and tough as they came, and his warm personality made him one of the most beloved figures in Yankees history. His wisdom, delivered in that wonderfully unique way of his, has brought smiles to fans for generations.

Shop the Yogi Berra plaque ($16) →

Babe Ruth

The Sultan of Swat was the heartbeat of the Yankees dynasty and, some would argue, the most iconic figure in American sports history. Ruth transformed the game with his thunderous home run hitting and helped deliver multiple World Series championships to the Bronx. His legacy is the foundation everything else in Yankees history is built upon.

Shop the Babe Ruth plaque ($26) →

Joe DiMaggio

The Yankee Clipper played the game with a grace and elegance that felt almost effortless, and he delivered championships when they mattered most. DiMaggio's legendary hitting streak captured the imagination of an entire nation and still stands as one of baseball's most celebrated records. He was the living definition of Yankee pride.

Shop the Joe DiMaggio plaque ($26) →

The Whole Lineup on One Plaque

Can't pick just one? The New York Yankees All-Time Greats plaque brings the franchise legends together on a single piece.

Shop the New York Yankees All-Time Greats plaque ($52) →