If your gift recipient bleeds orange and blue, you have a deep well to draw from. The Broncos have three Lombardi trophies, two Hall of Fame quarterbacks in John Elway and Peyton Manning, the Terrell Davis blueprint of a championship runner, and now Bo Nix as the new face of the franchise. The trick is matching the gift to where they sit on the fandom spectrum: lifelong season-ticket type, casual Sunday watcher, or the kid who just got handed a Broncos jersey for their birthday. Here are four picks at four price points that cover all of them.
1. Broncos All-Time Greats Plaque (8 cards, 12x15)
This is the one to lead with for any serious Broncos fan. Eight cards on a single 12x15 plaque covering the franchise legends: John Elway, Peyton Manning, Terrell Davis, and the rest of the Mile High pantheon. It is the wall-anchor piece, the kind of thing that goes up in a fan cave or home office and stays there. At $52 it punches well above its weight as a milestone gift, and it ships fast.
Shop 1. Broncos All-Time Greats Plaque (8 cards, 12x15) →
2. Super Bowl 50 Champions Plaque (Peyton Manning, 12x15)
If the fan you are shopping for remembers exactly where they were in February 2016, this is the gift. Peyton Manning's ride-off-into-the-sunset Super Bowl, captured across eight cards on a 12x15 plaque alongside the rest of that championship roster. Von Miller terrorizing Cam Newton, the best defense in football, Manning lifting the Lombardi one last time. $52, and it tells a complete story on the wall.
Shop 2. Super Bowl 50 Champions Plaque (Peyton Manning, 12x15) →
3. John Elway 4x6 Plaque ($14)
Sometimes you just need something thoughtful at a real gift-table price point. This 4x6 John Elway plaque is exactly that. Number 7, the helicopter run, two Super Bowl rings, the franchise GOAT (sorry Peyton) on a desk-sized plaque for $14. Perfect as a stocking stuffer, a coworker gift, a little something for the Broncos kid in the family, or as an add-on to a bigger gift. Hard to miss with this one.
Shop 3. John Elway 4x6 Plaque ($14) →
4. 2024 Score Team Set Gift Pack + 2023 Donruss + 20-Card Pack
For the fan who likes to actually hold the cards and flip through them, this is the move. You get the full 2024 Score Broncos team set (including the Bo Nix rookie card, #332), the 2023 Donruss team set, and a bonus 20-card pack stacked with Elway and current-roster names. Three layers of Broncos in one gift for $25. Great for a younger fan starting their collection, or for a longtime fan who wants the new guard sitting next to John Elway in the same binder.
Shop 4. 2024 Score Team Set Gift Pack + 2023 Donruss + 20-Card Pack →
Four gifts, four price points, all Broncos through and through. The All-Time Greats plaque is the showpiece, the Super Bowl 50 plaque is the story piece, the Elway 4x6 is the easy thoughtful add, and the team set gift pack is the one for the fan who wants something to open and shuffle through. Any of them ships fast and arrives ready to give. Mile High forever.
For more options, browse the Denver Broncos cards & plaques collection.