Spanning two cities and more than seven decades, the Colts boast one of the richest legacies in pro football, from the Baltimore championship teams of the 1950s and 60s to the Peyton Manning dynasty in Indianapolis. Ranking the greatest Indianapolis Colts players of all time means honoring the full franchise history, weighing Pro Football Hall of Famers from both eras. Here is our ranked list of the legends who wore the horseshoe.
1. Peyton Manning (QB · 1998-2011)
One of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history, Manning won four of his five league MVP awards in Indianapolis and led the Colts to victory in Super Bowl XLI. He rewrote the franchise and league passing records and made the team a perennial championship contender for over a decade.
2. Johnny Unitas (QB · 1956-1972)
The original Colts icon, Unitas won three league MVP awards and led Baltimore to two NFL titles and a Super Bowl victory. His performance in the 1958 'Greatest Game Ever Played' helped define modern football. He was a charter member of pro football's all-time elite.
3. Gino Marchetti (DE · 1953-1966)
Regarded as one of the finest defensive ends ever, Marchetti was named First-Team All-Pro nine times and helped Baltimore win two NFL Championships. His relentless pass rush set the standard at his position, earning him a place on the league's 50th and 75th anniversary teams.
4. Marvin Harrison (WR · 1996-2008)
Manning's favorite target and one of the most precise route runners ever, Harrison set the single-season reception record with 143 catches in 2002. An eight-time Pro Bowler in Indianapolis, he was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 2016.
5. Lenny Moore (RB · 1956-1967)
A dual-threat halfback and flanker, Moore scored 113 career touchdowns and helped Baltimore to two NFL titles. A seven-time Pro Bowler known for his big-play ability, he was enshrined in the Hall of Fame in 1975 as one of the era's most versatile weapons.
6. Raymond Berry (WR · 1955-1967)
A pioneer of precise route running and sure hands, Berry teamed with Unitas to form one of football's first great passing combinations. He set NFL receiving records and won two championships with Baltimore before his 1973 Hall of Fame induction.
7. Reggie Wayne (WR · 2001-2014)
A model of consistency and toughness, Wayne caught over 1,000 passes and surpassed 14,000 receiving yards across fourteen seasons, all in Indianapolis. A six-time Pro Bowler and Super Bowl champion, he was a key piece of the Manning-era offense.
8. Dwight Freeney (DE · 2002-2012)
Famous for his devastating spin move, Freeney was one of the premier pass rushers of his generation. A seven-time Pro Bowler with the Colts and a Super Bowl champion, he terrorized quarterbacks and anchored the Indianapolis pass rush for over a decade.
9. Edgerrin James (RB · 1999-2005)
An explosive and durable runner, James led the NFL in rushing in each of his first two seasons. The featured back of the early Manning-era offense, he became the franchise's leading rusher and earned Hall of Fame induction in 2020.
10. Art Donovan (DT · 1950-1961)
A cornerstone of Baltimore's championship defenses, Donovan was a five-time Pro Bowler and key figure on the 1958 and 1959 title teams. The first Colt enshrined in the Hall of Fame, he was a dominant interior defender and beloved franchise figure.
Honorable Mentions
Robert Mathis (Franchise sack leader, dynamic edge rusher), Jim Parker (Hall of Fame offensive lineman, Baltimore era), John Mackey (Hall of Fame trailblazing tight end), Ted Hendricks (Hall of Fame linebacker, Baltimore start), Mike Curtis (Hard-hitting Super Bowl V linebacker), Eric Dickerson (Star running back, Indianapolis years), Jeff Saturday (Pro Bowl center, Manning's anchor)
Put a Colts Legend on Your Wall
Own a piece of Indianapolis Colts history with hand-built plaques made from real licensed cards. Start with the Colts All-Time Greats plaque, or browse the full Indianapolis Colts collection. See legends from every team on our Pro Football Hall of Fame page. We ship nationwide.